CHAPTER
TWO
Review of Related Literature
This
chapter presents the review of related literature on the extent of provision and utilization of free MCHS
among the childbearing mothers in Igbo-Eze North LGA of Enugu State.
Literature on the subject abound. A few of them are from Nigeria while a great
number of them are conducted elsewhere in foreign countries. The review of
related literature is organized under the following headings:
Conceptual Framework
· Concept
of maternal and child health services (MCHS)
· Provision
and Utilization of health services.
· Measurement
of extent of provision and utilization of MCHS
· Demographic
factors associated with the extent of utilization of free MCHS.
Theoretical
Framework
·
Theory of health seeking-behaviour.
·
Theory of attachment.
Empirical
Studies on Extent of Provision and Utilization of Free MCH Services
Summary of Literature
Review
Conceptual Framework
This section will
review the concepts of MCHS, and extent of provision and utilization of MCHS.
Numerous researchers have defined MCHS diversely. However, most of them have
common conceptual focus.
Concept
of maternal and child health services.
Maternal
and child health services (MCHS) are those health services provided for childbearing
mothers and their children to protect them from sickness, trauma and death. Department of Education and Early Childhood-DEEC (2013)
defined Maternal and Child Health Service as a universal primary care service
for families with children from birth to school age. The targets for MCHS
are all women in their reproductive age groups, i.e., 15 - 49 years of age,
children, school age population and adolescents (Addisse, 2003). Oklahoma State
Department of Health-OSDH, (2013) added that MCHS’s mission is to provide state
leadership, in partnership with key stake holders, to improve the physical and
mental health, safety and well-being of the mother and child population. The service provides a comprehensive and focused
approach for the promotion, prevention, early detection, and intervention of
the physical, emotional or social factors affecting the health of young
children and their families in contemporary communities (DEEC, 2013).
MCHS
is aimed at helping to improve the health of mothers and their newborns in
order to reduce maternal and child morbidity and mortality. This may be only possible
if the services are accessible to mothers and children in terms of financial
cost. This may be why the Department of Health and Human Services-DHHS (2010)
described MCHS as a broad array of programmes organized to improve the
availability of and access to high quality preventive and primary health care
for all children and to reproductive health care for all woman and their
partners regardless of their ability to pay. In the present study, MCH services
are those health services given to
mothers and their children regardless of their ability to pay for the services
in order to reduce the rate of maternal and child death and achieve the optimal
health for both the mother and her child. Programmes under MCHS may include maternal
health and child health.
Maternal health services (MHS) are all the health care services a mother
receives during pregnancy, childbirth and after child birth. Onuzulike (2004)
defined MHS as health or health-related care fashioned towards helping mother
to cope successfully with physical or psychological strains under which they
are exposed to in the course of fulfilling their roles as wives and mothers.
Mothers need assistance in their childbearing period because they face with a
lot of challenges in this period. Federal Ministry of Health-FMOH (2007)
identified that during pregnancy and childbirth, mothers are always challenged
by conditions such as haemorrhage, puerperal, sepsis, obstructed labour, unsafe
abortion and pregnancy-induced hypertension. Others are malaria, HIV and
AIDs, diabetes mellitus and
hepatitis. This makes the mothers
a vulnerable
group. In the
context of this study, MHS means health services for the mother during
pregnancy, childbirth and 6 months after delivery. Maternal health services may
include prenatal care, antenatal care, delivery care, and postpartum care.
Others are family planning, emergency obstetric care, and post-abortion care.
Pre-conception
cares are health actions directed toward preparing a mother for a safe and a
risky-free pregnancy and child-bearing. PATHS (2005), and Ara and Islam (2013)
described pre-conception care as the information and services (such as
screening for and managing conditions which may complicate pregnancy,
childbirth and health of the mother and child) given to an individual or couple
who intend to biologically father or mother a child. According to Holt (2008), pre-conception counseling may
include assessment of lifestyle such as diet, exercise, consumption of alcohol
or tobacco, and ways of dealing with stress; recommendation of vitamins;
administration of necessary vaccinations; and general advice about maintaining
healthy habits. Koblinsky and Corberff (1987) observed
that the risk of maternal death is up to 15 times higher for women who do not
receive pre-natal care than it is for those who do. However, when a woman
eventually gets pregnant, she needs antenatal care for her welfare and that of
her unborn child.
Antenatal
care is the care of the women during pregnancy. Park (2014) defined antenatal care as the care which mothers
receive from healthcare professionals during their pregnancies. The
above report further noted that the purpose of
antenatal care is to monitor mothers’ health, the babies’ health and support
families to make child-bearing plans which are right for them. During
pregnancy, it is very important that mother takes good care of her own health
and that of her baby. This includes taking good nutrition at appropriate
quantity and quality. According to UNFPA (2014), the primary objective
of antenatal care is to establish contact with the women, and identify and
manage current
and potential
risks and problems. UNFPA (2014)
maintained that this creates the opportunity for the woman and
her health care provider to establish a delivery plan based on her unique
needs, resources and circumstances. Therefore, the delivery plan identifies her
intentions about where and with whom she intends to give birth and contingency
plans in the event of complications (transport, place of referral, etc). With
this, a mother may be guaranteed a safe-delivery.
Safe-delivery is a
procedure of assisting women who undergo rigorous labour processes and
peurperium without injury, infection or any form of morbidity (PATHS, 2005). If
pregnant women are handled effectively during labour, the factors that lead to
maternal mortality and morbidity may be drastically reduced. After delivery, a mother still needs a postpartum
care.
A woman, in the course
of childbirth may undergo enormous physiological and emotional stress. She
needs to be cared for after delivery so that she may fully recover from the
pains accompanying childbirth. This care is known as postpartum care. Adama
(2008) defined postpartum care as the care given to mothers after delivery to
recuperate from injuries associated with childbirth. This seems to reverse the
physiological changes that occurred during pregnancy and delivery, and to
restore the body to its pre-pregnancy state. During this period, breastfeeding
is established, and family planning is introduced to avert early occurrence of
another pregnancy (Lucas & Gilles, 2003).
Family planning
involves the management of number and space of births. Derek (1993) described
family planning as a means of helping individuals and couples choose the number
of children they will have. He added that the choice depends on a complicated
mixture of social, cultural and psychological influences. PATHS (2005) defined
family planning as a way of thinking and living adopted voluntarily upon the
basis of knowledge, attitudes and responsible decisions by individual and
couples in order to promote the health of family and thus contribute
effectively to the social development of the country. Another care for the
mother worth discussing is abortion and post-abortion care.
Abortion means
termination of pregnancy before the end of its term. It is the death or
expulsion of the foetus either spontaneously or by induction before the 28th
week of the pregnancy (Myles, 2009). According to Umar (1993), abortion
involves the detachment, forcing out or expulsion of the incompletely developed
foetus or embryo from the mother’s womb before viability. Abortion always comes
with complications making post-abortion care very necessary.
Post-abortion care
means after-abortion care. This means care given to a woman following abortion.
NPSM (2003) described post-abortion as offering contraception to a woman who
has experienced an abortion complication as a way of preventing subsequent
abortion. The above report recommended the need for administration of broad
spectrum antibiotics intravenous fluids, and blood transfusion to prevent,
infection, de-hydration and anaemia that may lead to maternal morbidity or mortality.
In addition to the foregoing, mothers need obstetric and other maternal cares.
Emergency obstetric
care and Life saving skills are cares given to a woman to ensure that risks of
complications associated with pregnancy and delivery are prevented. Emergency
obstetric care and Life saving skills are targeted towards saving the life and
promoting the health of the mother and her child in the course of and after
delivery (PATHS, 2005). UNFPA (2014) advised that since up to 50 per cent of
maternal deaths occur after delivery, a midwife or a trained and supervised
Traditional Birth Attendant (TBA) should visit all mothers as soon as possible
within the first 24-48 hours after birth. Ara and Islam (2013) advised that the
midwife or TBA should assess the mother's general condition and recovery after
childbirth and identify any special needs. A child also needs health services.
Child health services
(CHS) are services directed towards ensuring that a child is totally healthy.
WHO (2000) defined CHS as an aspect of modern services specifically designed
for health promotion, disease prevention, and treatment of children under five
years of age. According to Park (2009), CHS is that branch of medical science
that deals with the care of children from conception to childhood, in health
and disease. According to Bennette (2004), CHS comprises immunization services,
promotion of breastfeeding, oral rehydration therapy, nutrition education,
antennal and postnatal treatment of minor prevalent illnesses as well as outreach
programmes. In the present study, CHS refers to an aspect of modern services
specifically designed for health promotion, disease prevention, and treatment
of children under five years of age. AlHilfy and Esaa (2007) had aptly noted
that mothers and children are vulnerable groups that need special care through
maternal care; for women in the child-bearing period, especially the pregnant
and lactating, and through child care; for children below five years infants
and preschool children. If all these programmes are fully pursued, the rates of
morbidity and mortality may be reduced to the barest minimum among the under 5
and childbearing mothers.
A childbearing mother is one in her reproductive age (i.e. between
puberty and menopause). She may be described as that woman who has the natural
capability to conceive and give birth, and who may be between the ages of 12 to
49 or above. Child-bearing age has been described as the period in a woman’s life between puberty and
menopause (Williams & Wilkins, 2006). Experts, as reported by Medical News
Today-MNT (2005), advised that the best age for childbearing remains
20-35. MNT (2005) warned that
age-related fertility problems increase after 35 and dramatically after 40.
Under-aged mothers may also be at the high risk of pregnancy-related
complication. WHO (2012) reported that young adolescents face a higher
risk of complications and death as a result of pregnancy than older women.
Studies like Jatau (2000), and Williams and Wilkins (2006) showed that
adolescent pregnancy is an exploding problem in Sub-Saharan Africa. Young women
under 20 years of age in Africa are more likely to have a child than those in
other regions (Daly, Azefor & Nasah, 1993). For example, by age 18 more
than 40 percent of the women in Africa have given birth already (Senderwitz
1993). In clarifying this, Daly, Azefor and Nasah (1993) reported that in
Africa, 1 in 5 adolescent women will have a birth in a given year. They noted
that most of the births to teenagers are first births and women having their
first child carry higher risk of serious medical complications. The above
report further reveals that babies who are first births face a higher infant
mortality rate than higher order births and this risk is even greater for
teenage mothers. However, a childbearing mother (also interchangeably used with
women of childbearing age) in this study is a woman who is in a period between
her puberty and menopause, and who still give birth to a child. If necessary
cares are not made available and accessible to childbearing mothers, there may
be increase in the rate of maternal morbidity.
Maternal morbidity is a pregnancy related health problems or disabilities
which women suffer during or after childbirth, but not result into death (NPSM,
2003). Price (2002) reported that an estimated 40 per cent and above of
pregnant women, which equivalent to 50 million women experience pregnancy
related health problems during or after childbirth each year. The report
further indicated that 15 per cent of these women suffer severe or long-term,
often dilapidating complications such as uterine prolapsed (sliding of the
uterus from its normal position), fistulae (hole in the vagina), pelvic
inflammatory disease (PID), and infertility. These complications if not well
managed may lead to maternal mortality.
Maternal
mortality is the number of deaths of childbearing mothers in a year due to
pregnancy or childbirth. Maternal mortality is the annual number of women who
die from pregnancy- or childbirth-related complications per 100,000 live births
(Indexmundi, 2013). According to Addisse (2003) maternal mortality is defined
as the death of a woman while pregnant or within 42 days of termination of
pregnancy irrespective of the site and duration of pregnancy from any acutely
related to or aggravated by the pregnancy or its management but not from
accidental or incidental causes.
The rate of maternal
mortality is found to be associated with lifetime risk of mothers among other
factors. The joint report of WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA and the World Bank (2012) described
lifetime risk as the probability that a woman will die from complications of
pregnancy and childbirth over her lifetime; it takes into account both the
maternal mortality ratio and the total fertility rate (probable number of
births per woman during her reproductive years). Thus in a high-fertility
setting a woman faces the risk of maternal death multiple times, and her
lifetime risk of death will be higher than in a low-fertility setting. The
lifetime risk of maternal death in the developing world in 2010 as a whole was
1 in 150, compared with industrialized regions with an estimated 1 in 4,700.
Among the regions, women in sub-Saharan Africa face the highest lifetime risk
– one maternal death in every 39 births. However, maternal death or
illness appears to affect her children and entire household. According to Canadian Institute for Health
Information-CIHI (2001), a woman's death during childbirth may lead to the death of
the child. This is known as child mortality.
Child mortality is the annual number of deaths of children below the age
of 5 years per 100,000 live births (Indexmundi, 2013). Maternal and infant
death may be prevented by ensuring that maternal health complications are
recognized, referred, and treated by skilled health care and that women and
children access high quality MCHS. However, for MCHS to achieve its aim depends
on the extent of its provision.
Extent of provision implies the degree of supply or availability of
something. The word ‘extent’ is synonymous to ‘degree’. According to Farlex
(2013), ‘extent’ means the range, magnitude, or distance over which a thing
extends. Babylon (2014) described ‘extent’ as how
much; how many; or what degree. The word “extent’ in this study means
how much. Also in the present study, it is used as extent of provision.
Provision means supply or availability of something. Farlex (2014)
defined provision in three distinct ways thus: i) the act of supplying or
fitting out: ii) something provided: and iii) a stock of necessary supplies.
According to Vocabulary.com (2013), a provision is a store or supply of
something like food or clothing. The above definitions agree that provision is
making something available. In this study, provision means the supply of health
facilities necessary for MCHS. This study will concentrate on the extent of
provision of MCHS. However, extent of provision of MCHS may influence its
utilization.
Utilization means making use of something or finding a practical or
effective use for something. Farlex (2013) described it as an act of using
something. This work is interested in service utilization. According to Hampton
and Nagy (2013), service utilization refers to the
extent to which people are making use of whatever services which are already
available in the community or at one’s organization. RobDavies (2013)
described utilization mathematically thus: it is the ratio of time a system is
busy (i.e. working for us), divided by the time it is available. For example,
if MCH services is available for 160 hours and busy for 40 hours only, then utilization
is 40/160= 0.25. So, there is 25 per cent of utilization. In this study, utilization refers to the extent at which
childbearing mothers and their children are making use of MCH services which
are available in the community. Adequate provision and utilization of
MCHS remain the proven tools for curbing the rates of mortality and morbidity
among women of child bearing age and their children. Extent of provision and
utilization of MCH services are measurable.
Measurement
of extent of provision and utilization of MCH services.
Measurement refers to the assignment of numerals to
objects or events according to rules (Nwachukwu, 2007). Nwachukwu noted that
measurement is conducted using instruments like a range, a scale or a test. Any
instrument capable of providing dependable measurement must possess certain
qualities such as validity, reliability and usability (Nwachukwu, 2007).
Provision and utilization may be regarded as
practices. Practice according to Hornby (2005) simply mean action. Therefore,
provision and utilization can be regarded as practice because both involve
action. In this study, methods applied in measuring practice will be applied in
the measurement of extent of provision and utilization of MCH services.
In measuring the extent of provision of MCH
services, the rating scale of “a large extent (LE)”, “some extent (SE)” and
“Never (N)” according Gemson (2011) can be
applied.
“YES” and “NO” option according to Enyi (2006) can be used to measure practice
(provision and utilization). Sometimes, question with multiple option where the
respondent is expected to choose an option can be used to measure practice. In
this study, the three options above will be employed to ascertain the extent of
provision and utilization of MCH services.
Importance
of provision and utilization of MCH services.
Increasing the
proportion of mothers who are cared for in health facilities during pregnancy,
childbirth and puerperium reduces the health risks and deaths of mothers and
their children. In MCH services, emphasis is placed on ensuring services to
childbearing women, infants, children, and adolescents (including children with
special health care needs, low income populations, those with poor nutritional
status and those who do not have access to health care) (UNICEF,
2013). This is the main function of MCH services
where provided. The importance of MCH services is not limited to the
health of mothers and children or their immediate problems. Rather, it shows
the role and necessity of MCH services in the welfare of the family, the
community and the country as a whole. Thus, MCH is an issue that has to be
addressed in terms of national productivity and futurity of a country.
UNICEF (2013) clamours the need for provision of MCH
services given that every single day,
Nigeria loses about 2,300 under-five year olds and 145 women of childbearing
age. This makes the country the second largest contributor to the under–five
and maternal mortality rate in the world.
Preventable or treatable infectious diseases such as
malaria, pneumonia, diarrhoea, measles and HIV/AIDS account for more than 70
per cent of the estimated one million under-five deaths in Nigeria (WHO, 2013).
UNICEF (2013) lamented that malnutrition is the underlying cause of morbidity
and mortality of a large proportion of children under-5 in Nigeria. It accounts
for more than 50 per cent of deaths of children in this age bracket. The deaths
of newborn babies in Nigeria represent a quarter of the total number of deaths
of children under-five.
Many of these deaths are preventable with MCH
services. Presently, less than 20 per cent of health facilities offer emergency
obstetric care and only 35 per cent of deliveries are attended by skilled birth
attendants (UNICEF, 2013). This justifies the need for provision of maternal
and child health interventions.
Addisse (2003) outlined the important considerations
and justifications for provision of MCHS thus: (i) Mothers and children make up over 2/3 of the whole population.
(ii) Women in reproductive age (15 – 49) constitute 21 per cent, pregnant
women, 4.5 per cent, and children under the age of 5, 47 per cent. This working
estimate may be very important in developing countries for project planning and
implementation. (iii) Maternal mortality is an adverse
outcome of many pregnancies. (iv) Miscarriage, induced abortion, and other
factors, are causes for over 40 per cent of the pregnancies in developing
countries to result in complications, illnesses, or permanent disability for
the mother or child. (v) About 80 per cent
of maternal deaths are related to obstetric deaths. They result from obstetric
complications of the pregnant state (pregnancy, labour, and puerperium), from
intervention, omissions, incorrect treatment, or from a chain of events
resulting from any of the above. (vi) Most pregnant women in the developing
world receive insufficient or no prenatal care and deliver without help from
appropriately trained health care providers. More than 7 million newborn deaths
are believed to result from maternal health problems and their mismanagement. (vii)
Poorly timed unwanted pregnancies carry high risks of morbidity and mortality,
as well as social and economic costs, particularly to the adolescent and many
unwanted pregnancies end in unsafe abortion. (viii) Poor maternal health hurts
women's productivity, their families' welfare, and socio-economic development.
The foregoing justifies the importance of MCHS.
Addisse (2003) noted that cultural attitudes and
practices impede women's use of MCH services that are available. The women also
lack access to relevant information, trained providers and supplies, emergency
transport, and other essential services. Addisse maintained that because many
women are fed less, marry early, carry a heavy workload, and spend a
considerable portion of their lifespan in pregnancy and lactation, they are
exposed to persistent low nutritional status and high-energy expenditure. This predisposes
mothers to bear low-birth-weight infants.
Demographic
factors associated with the extent of utilization of MCH services.
Certain variables have
been found to influence the extent of provision and utilization of MCH
services. One of such variables is economic status. It is well known that
increased income has a positive effect on the utilization of modern health care
services (Elo, 1992; Fosu, 1994). The study
conducted by Nitai, Islam, Chowdhury, Bari and
Akhter (1993) revealed
that women whose husbands worked in business or services were most likely to be
users of modern health care services to treat complications during pregnancy.
About 33.4 per cent of women whose husbands worked in business or services went
to some qualified medical personnel for treatment, compared with 24 per cent
among those whose husbands worked in agriculture or as day laborers. Also,
women's involvement in gainful employment empowers women to take part in
decision-making processes about health care in the family. About 35.4 per cent
of women who worked for cash went to some qualified medical personnel for
treatment, compared with only 25.3 per cent of those who did not work.
Husband's occupation can be considered a proxy of family income, as well as
social status. Audo, Ferguson
and Njoroge (2005)
reported that poor utilization of MCH services was
associated with the socio-economic status of the respondents.
Differences in attitudes
to modern health care services by occupational groups depict occupation as a
predisposing factor. Alternatively, viewing occupation as proxy to income,
which enables acquisition of more and better health care, depicts it as an
enabling factor (Fiedler, 1981). Vanden,
De Mey, Buddingh and Bots
(1999) found that unemployment and being without a
husband were associated with deliveries outside the hospital. The patients may
not have known their expected day of delivery (EDD) because they do not get
antenatal services. Unaffordable medical bills is a major barrier to
utilization of maternal and child healthcare services leading to a very high
maternal and perinatal mortality and the inability to attain the MDG4 and MDG5
in many developing countries (Okafor,
Obi &
Ugwu, (2011).
The result of the study conducted by Kiwanuka, Ekirapa, Peterson, Okui, Rahman, Peters and Pariyo (2008) indicated
that the poor and vulnerable ones experience a greater burden of disease and have
lower access to health services than the
rich ones. Mwaniki, Kabiru and Mbugua (2002) reported that lack of money for transport and hospital fee are
the major constraints experienced by the mothers as they sought for the
services. IRIN News (2006) reported that
the patients' inability to afford prescribed
medications is some of the challenges health officials are now facing.
The level of
utilization of MCH services is still very low even with the introduction of the
free MCH services. Suffice this to say that lack of or low level utilization of
MCH care is not only due to financial reasons. Other factors have been
consistently reported to influence the level of utilization of MCH care. One of
such factors is the mother’s level of education.
It is well recognized
that mother's education has a positive impact on health care utilization. Nitai, Islam, Chowdhury, Bari and
Akhter (1993) investigated
the determinants of the use of maternal health services in rural Bangladesh and
found that there were more educated women (34.6% ) than uneducated ones (26.5%)
who sought care from qualified medical personal for treating complications. The
study revealed that mother's education associated positively with treatment
received. Govindasamy
and Ramesh (1997) reported that a higher level of maternal education
results in improved child survival because health services that effectively
prevent fatal childhood diseases are used to a greater extent by mothers with
higher education than by those with little or no education. The study further
reported that the benefits of maternal education persist even when other
socioeconomic factors are taken into account. Elo (1992) reported quantitatively
important and statistically significant effect of mother's education on the use
of prenatal care and delivery assistance. In another study conducted by Becker, Peters, Gray, Gultiano and Blake (1993), it was found
that mother's education is the most consistent and important determinant of the
use of child and maternal health services.
It is argued that
better educated women are more aware of health problems, know more about the
availability of health care services, and use this information more effectively
to maintain or achieve good health status. Mother's education may also act as a
proxy variable of a number of background variables representing women's higher
socioeconomic status, thus enabling her to seek proper medical care whenever
she perceives it necessary. UNICEF (1997) reported that education is positively
associated with increased utilization of antenatal care. Nisar and White (2003)
observed that there are a number of explanations why education is a key
determinant of demand. The authors maintained that education is likely to
enhance female autonomy. Women therefore, develop greater confidence and
capabilities to make decisions regarding their own health, as well as their
children’s health. It is likely that more educated women seek higher quality
services and have greater ability to use health care inputs to produce better
health. In addition to maternal education, age of the mother may play important
role in the utilization of MCHS.
Mother's age may
sometimes serve as a proxy for the women's accumulated knowledge of health care
services, which may have a positive influence on the use of health services. On
the other hand, because of development of modern medicine and improvement in
educational opportunities for women in recent years, younger women might have
an enhanced knowledge of modern health care services and place more value upon
modern medicine. Nitai, Islam, Chowdhury, Bari and
Akhter (1993)
reported that older women are more likely to seek maternal health-care services
than younger women. About 42 per cent of older (age >35 years) respondents
sought care for any current complication from a doctor or nurse, compared with
28.5 per cent of younger women (age
<20 age="" also="" at="" em="" indicated="" marriage="" report="" that="" the="" years="">p20>
<
0.10) associated positively with treatment received.
The report of Owino (2012) contradicted the above finding.
Owino reported that maternal age also had a statistically significant
relationship with place of delivery; the chances of delivering at home were
greatest among older mothers aged 35 years and above; and the youngest age
group, of mothers aged from 15 to 24, had the most chances of delivering at a
health institution. Moreover, a greater percentage of mothers who delivered at
health institutions were lower parity women with 1 to 3 children. Over 70 per
cent of mothers of parity 7 and above delivered at home, compared to about 54
per cent of those of parity 1 to 3.
The above relationships
of age and parity concur with previous studies (such as Dissevelt, 1978;
Nginya, 1980; Winikoff, 1987; Obemeyer & Potter, 1991; Sargent &
Rawlings, 1991; Bulut, 1995) where it was reported that younger women tended to
deliver at a health facility for fear of complications during childbirth. Older
women, however, were observed to deliver at home confidently due to their
experience with previous births.
Some authors believe
that one would naturally seek care irrespective of one’s age. This means that
mother’s age has no connection with the attitude to and practice of safe
motherhood. Igbokwe and Adama (2011)
reported that age had no significance
influence on child-bearing mother’s practice of SMI components. The authors maintained that age of an individual
does not necessarily influence the individual's capacity to effectively practice health-related behaviour most
especially when the behaviour
is of immense benefit to the individual.
Studies
show that home-hospital distance influences the level of utilization of MCH
services. The location and quality of services available are also important
factors affecting MCH services utilization. Proximity to a health facility has
been found to affect the use of MCH services especially in rural areas (Rahaman
et al, 1982 in Chakraborty et al, 2003) as these facilities are usually located
at long distances. For many, lack of transportation and/or considerations of
the cost of transportation serve as mitigating factors to healthcare seeking.
Several
other studies also found that physical proximity of health care services,
especially in the developing countries, plays an important role in utilization
of these services (Stock, 1983; Airey, 1989; Paul, 1991). In this study,
‘access’ refers to the availability of MCH services in closer proximity to the
users. Rahaman (1982) reported that geographical distance is one of the most
important determinants of health care service utilization in rural areas. World
Bank (1999) and WHO (2012) listed distance, lack of information, inadequate
services, cultural practices among others as the obstacle to the utilization of
MCHS. The present study focuses on mother’s economic status, level of
education, age and distance as they influence the extent of utilization of MCH
services.
Figure
1 above is the conceptual framework generated by the present researcher in
explaining the level of provision and utilization of free MCH services among
the child-bearing mothers and their children. There are two routes to getting
MCH services: route A and B.
When sickness strikes
or when there is need to seek medical attention, one is always confronted with
obstacle that might hinder one from getting the right type of medical
attention. One might choose any of the routes. Route A above is when the
patients resiliently seek care notwithstanding factors such as financial
constraints, distance among others. When one passes through obstacles, the
route is always rough. The dotted arrow in route A indicates rough route. The
patient eventually accesses the MCH services.
Route
B is an escapist and seemingly easier route from on set. The patient makes a
U-turn in the face of an obstacle. She takes an alternative decision which
might be to ignore the sign or to pray. Some resort to alternative medicine.
They complain of the medical bills, distance, unyielding husband, cultural
barriers among others, as factors hindering them from receiving care. This
might lead to complications or worsened condition. Then, the patient would be
rushed to the hospital through the roughest route ignoring cultural barriers
and financial constraints indicted earlier.
Most times,
complications may lead to maternal and child morbidity and/or mortality. There
may be still birth, pre-term delivery among others.
Theoretical
Frame Work
Theories are
constructs and postulations that guide or suggest a way in which individuals
perceive phenomena and act or behave which in turn may influence the nature and
the level of what they know or practice. The way individuals get information or
behave is assumed or believed to depend on a person’s scheme (Illaete, 1980).
The scheme attempts to know (knowledge), how they want to get the information
(methods of learning) and how, what or which of the facts (knowledge) they want
to act on (attitude). The theory is an idea or belief about something arrived
through speculation or conjecture (Microsoft Encarta, 2009).
This study will therefore be anchored on
theory of health seeking-behaviour and theory of attachment in explaining the
level of provision and utilization of free MCH services among mothers of
child-bearing age in Igbo-Eze North LGA of Enugu State.
Theory
of health seeking-behaviour.
Health care utilization
is the point in health systems where patients’ needs meet the professional
system. It is well known that apart from need-related factors, health care
utilization is also supply-induced and thus strongly dependent on the
structures of the health care system. Furthermore, many study findings have
shown differences in health care utilization based on patients’ social
characteristics. For instance, women tend to use outpatient health care
services more often than men. In addition to the multitude of studies
describing patterns of utilization in different health care settings, several
scholars have developed explanatory frameworks identifying predictors of health
care utilization. One of the most widely acknowledged is the theory
of health seeking-behaviour by Anderson and Newman (1973).
The theory has a multilevel model that incorporates
both individual and contextual determinants of health services use. In doing
so, it divides the major components of contextual characteristics in the same
way as individual characteristics have traditionally been divided—those that
predispose, enable , or suggest need for individual use of health services (Andersen, 2008). In their most recent explication
of the model, Andersen & Davidson (2001) described these three major components
as follows: (i) Predisposing
factors. Individual
predisposing factors include the demographic characteristics of age and sex as
“biological imperatives” , social factors such as education, occupation,
ethnicity and social relationships (e.g., family status), and mental factors in
terms of health beliefs (e.g., attitudes, values, and knowledge related to
health and health services). Contextual factors predisposing individuals to the
use of health services include the demographic and social composition of
communities, collective and organizational values, cultural norms and political
perspectives.
Enabling factors are factors such
as financing and organizational factors which are
considered to serve as conditions enabling services utilization. Individual
financing factors involve the income and wealth at an individual’s disposal to
pay for health services and the effective price of health care which is
determined by the individual’s health insurance status and cost-sharing
requirements. Organizational factors entail whether an individual has a regular
source of care and the nature of that source. They also include means of
transportation, travel time to and waiting time for health care. At the
contextual level, financing encompasses the resources available within the
community for health services, such as per capita community income, affluence,
the rate of health insurance coverage, the relative price of goods and
services, methods of compensating providers, and health care expenditures.
Organization at this level refers to the amount, varieties, locations,
structures and distribution of health services facilities and personnel. It
also involves physician and hospital density, office hours, provider mix,
quality management oversight, and outreach and education programs. Health policies
also fall into the category of contextual enabling factors.
The third factor is the need factors. At the individual level, there is
difference between perceived need for health services (i.e., how people view
and experience their own general health, functional state and illness symptoms)
and evaluated need (i.e., professional assessments and objective measurements
of patients’ health status and need for medical care). At the contextual level,
they make a distinction between environmental need characteristics and
population health indices. Environmental need reflects the health-related
conditions of the environment (e.g., occupational and traffic and crime-related
injury and death rates). Population health indices are overall measures of
community health, including epidemiological indicators of mortality, morbidity,
and disability.
According to Andersen and Newman (1973), the need factor is
the most immediate cause of health service use. The need factor reflects the
perceived health status, as indicated by severity of the morbidity conditions
or the number of morbidities. The presence of predisposing and enabling
components may not be enough for a mother to seek health care. She must
perceive the disease as serious and believe that the treatment will provide the
expected benefits (Fosu, 1994). Need represents the most immediate
cause of health service use. The need for health care can be measured in a
variety of ways: self-perceived health status, number of morbidity symptoms, or
duration and severity of disability (Fiedler, 1981). Perceived severity or number of
episodes of diseases has a positive association with greater MCH care
utilization among the child-bearing mothers. However, this theory will be used in
the present work to explain factors that determine the level of provision and
utilization of MCH services.
Attachment theory.
Attachment
theory focuses on the relationships and bonds between people, particularly
long-term relationships including those between a patients and health-care
provider. Attachment is an emotional bond to another person (Cherry, 2013). According to Ciechanowski, Walker, Katon and Russo
(2002) Theory of Attachment is a framework of ideas that attempt to explain
attachment, the almost universal human tendency to prefer certain familiar
companions over other people, especially when ill, injured, or distressed. Psychologist, Bowlby (1969), was the first
attachment theorist, describing attachment as a lasting psychological connectedness
between human beings.
Bowlby (1969)
believed that the earliest bonds formed by children with their caregivers have
a tremendous impact that continues throughout life. He suggested attachment
also serves to keep the infant close to the mother, thus improving the child's
chances of survival. The central theme of attachment theory is that primary
caregivers who are available and responsive to an infant's needs allow the
child to develop a sense of security (Cherry, 2013). The infant knows that the
caregiver is dependable, which creates a secure base for the child to then
explore the world.
This analogy
can be extended to the patients-health providers relationship. People get
attached to health providers who give them sense of health security. This is
why a patient likes one doctor or nurse more than the other(s). If his/her
doctor or nurse is no longer at the hospital (may be transferred), he/she finds
it difficult to continue using the health services in the hospital. Moreover, a
patient may have the same attachment to a particular hospital just as an infant
knows that its care-giver is dependable. He/she believes that the hospital has
genuine drugs, trained health personnel among other reason.
Figure
2 above is a theoretical framework adapted from the work of Fraley and Shaver.
The researcher modified the framework to suit the present discourse. The double
arrows linking the two theories are used to demonstrate that the two theories
agree that people are always attracted to where things that catch their
interest. When the patients’ needs (such as cost of medication, personnel of
interest among others) are met in the arrow tagged “yes”, they feel loved,
secured and confident, and level of MCH services utilization increases. Depression,
anger and frustration set in when these needs are not met (see the arrow tagged
“NO”). Patients may resort to withdrawal. Some patients may begin to look for
another way out while others may remain at home not looking for alternate help.
Empirical
Studies
Nitai, Islam, Chowdhury, Bari and Akhter (1993) examined
the factors that influence the use of maternal health care services in
Bangladesh. Prospective data obtained from the survey on Maternal Morbidity in
Bangladesh, which was conducted by the Bangladesh Institute of Research for
Promotion of Essential and Reproductive Health and Technologies (BIRPERHT) was
used. Data collection spanned the period from November 1992 to
December 1993. The study had two components: cross-sectional and prospective.
The paper employed data from the prospective component.
Multi-stage random sampling was
employed to collect data on maternal morbidity. One district from each of four
divisions was selected in the first stage. In the second stage, one thana (a
thana contains several ‘unions’, comprising a population size of 0.2–0.25
million) from each selected district was selected randomly. Finally, two unions
(unions consist of several ‘wards’, which are small geographical boundaries
comprising villages in rural areas) from each selected thana were considered
study areas. For the prospective study, 1020 pregnant women (pregnant for <6 1020="" 993="" antenatal="" at="" follow-up="" had="" interviewed.="" least="" months="" o:p="" of="" one="" out="" pregnant="" selected.="" were="" who="" women="">6>
The results showed that older women
are more likely to seek maternal health-care
services than younger women. The results from the study indicated a U-shaped
relationship with birth order and the use of health services to treat maternal
morbidities. The percentage of women who
sought care from a doctor, nurse or FWV to treat any complications decreases
from 29 per cent in women with no previous pregnancies to 26.1 per cent in
mothers with one to four previous pregnancies; it increases again to 35.1 per
cent in women with five or more previous pregnancies. The use of traditional
and other health services related to the number of previous pregnancies also
show a similar pattern.
The results show a U-shaped relation
between family size and the use of health services for treating any
complications during pregnancy. The percentage of women who sought care from
qualified medical personnel, i.e. a doctor, nurse or FWV, to treat
complications decreases from 30.3 per cent in women with less than four family
members to 23.2 per cent among mothers with four to six family members, and
increases again to 33.6 per cent in women with seven or more family members.
The use of traditional and other health services does not show a similar
pattern in relation to family size.
The results from this study also
support the positive association between the level of mother's education and
health care utilization. The results indicate that
female education has a net effect on maternal health service use, independent
of other background characteristics, household socioeconomic status and access
to health care services. The percentage of women who sought care from
qualified medical personal for treating complications increases from 26.5 per
cent among illiterate women to 34.6 per cent among women with secondary or
higher education.
The study revealed that women whose husbands worked in
business or services were most likely to be users of modern health care
services to treat complications during pregnancy. About 33.4 per cent of women
whose husbands worked in business or services went to some qualified medical
personnel for treatment, compared with 24 per cent among those whose husbands
worked in agriculture or as day laborers. Also, women's involvement in gainful
employment empowers women to take part in decision-making processes about
health care in the family. About 35.4 per cent of women who worked for cash
went to some qualified medical personnel for treatment, compared with only 25.3
per cent of those who did not work.
There was no substantial difference
in utilization of health care services for complications according to how far
respondents lived from health facilities. This result is quite surprising
because the respondents residing in close proximity to health care services are
more likely to use them. The study finally revealed that mother's education (p <
0.05), age at marriage (p < 0.10) and type of housing (p <
0.10) appeared to be associated positively with treatment received, while
family size (p <
0.10) was negatively associated with receiving treatment for complications.
Vanden, De Mey, Buddingh, and Bots (1999) conducted a research which aimed at determining
the coverage of antenatal and delivery care and the determinants of
non-compliance in a rural area of Zimbabwe in order to improve the quality and
efficiency of maternal health care services. A community-based, cross-sectional
study was carried out in the catchment area of Gutu Mission Hospital, in rural
Zimbabwe, from January to June 1996. Two hundred and thirty-five women, aged 16
to 54 years, who had delivered a child in the past three years, were
interviewed on general characteristics (age, marital status, religion,
education, work), obstetric history, use of family planning, pregnancy
complications, number of antenatal visits, and use of maternity waiting
shelters. Associations of these factors to non-use of antenatal care facilities
and hospital delivery were studied. In the Gutu district, guidelines exist to
identify women at high risk of complications during pregnancy and to indicate
where women should give birth (hospital, rural clinic or at home). The study
evaluated which factors were important for non-compliance to these guidelines.
The analyses were performed using a logistic regression model.
Results
show that 97 per cent of the pregnant women attended the antenatal care
facilities at least once. 73 per cent came at least five times or more. The level of mother's education influenced
health care utilization. Belonging to certain
religious groups proved to be the strongest explanatory factor for not
attending antenatal care facilities. Use of maternity waiting shelters and
complications during the pregnancy were important factors for hospital
delivery, whereas unemployment and being without a husband were associated with
deliveries outside the hospital. Identification as high risk of a complicated
pregnancy by application of the existing guidelines was not associated with
place of delivery. Delivery at a location that did not conform to the existing
guidelines was associated with non-use of maternity waiting shelters,
unemployment or being without a husband and use of traditional care.
Kiwanuka, Ekirapa,
Peterson, Okui, Rahman,
Peters
and Pariyo (2008) conducted a systematic review of socio-economic
differences in morbidity and access to health care in Uganda. It includes
published studies from electronic databases and official reports from surveys
done by government, bilateral and multilateral agencies and universities.
The
outcome measures studied were: the distribution of HIV/AIDS; maternal and child
morbidity; and access to and utilisation of health services for people
belonging to different socio-economic and vulnerability groups. Forty-eight of
678 identified studies met the inclusion criteria for the study. Results
indicated that the poor and vulnerable experience a greater burden of disease
but have lower access to health services than the less poor. Barriers to access
arise from both the service providers and the consumers. Distance to service
points, perceived quality of care and availability of drugs are key
determinants of utilization. Other barriers are perceived lack of skilled staff
in public facilities, late referrals, health worker attitude, costs of care and
lack of knowledge.
Govindasamy and Ramesh (1997) conducted a
study to ascertain the relationship between maternal education and the utilization of maternal and child health
services in India. Using data from the National Family Health
Survey 1992–93, they examined the relationship between maternal schooling and factors
known to reduce the risks of maternal and child mortality, namely, healthcare
practices, for some selected northern and southern states in India. They hypothesized
that the practices of educated women are quite different from those of
uneducated women with regard to pregnancy, childbirth, immunization, and
management of childhood diseases such as diarrhoea and acute respiratory
infection (ARI). However, there exist a number of confounding factors such as socioeconomic
status that are associated with the study of the impact of maternal education
on health-care utilization.
The hypothesis that the relationship between
mother’s education and healthcare practices might be the result of other
variables was tested, and regression analysis on several of these variables was
carried out. It was evident that a higher level of maternal education results
in improved child survival because health services that effectively prevent
fatal childhood diseases are used to a greater extent by mothers with higher education
than by those with little or no education. The study concluded that the
benefits of maternal education persist even when other socioeconomic factors
are taken into account.
Ditekemena
(2013) conducted a study which aimed at identifying
the determinants of male partners’ involvement in MCH activities, focusing
specifically on HIV prevention of maternal to child transmission (PMTCT) in
sub-Saharan Africa. Source of information was through the following data bases:
Pubmed/MEDLINE; CINAHL; EMBASE; COCHRANE; Psych INFORMATION and the websites of
the International AIDS Society (IAS), the International AIDS Conference and the
International Conference on AIDS in Africa (ICASA) 2011.
It was found that the majority of
studies defined male participation as male involvement solely during antenatal
HIV testing. Other studies defined male involvement as any male participation
in HIV couple counseling. The study identified three main determinants for male
participation in PMTCT services: 1) Socio-demographic factors such as level of
education, income status; 2) health services related factors such as opening
hours of services, behavior of health providers and the lack of space to
accommodate male partners; and 3) Sociologic factors such as beliefs, attitudes
and communication between men and women.
It was concluded in the study that there
are many challenges to increase male involvement/participation in PMTCT
services and that few interventions addressing these challenges have been
evaluated and reported. The study recommended that improvement of antenatal
care services by making them more male friendly, and health education campaigns
to change beliefs and attitudes of men are absolutely needed.
As unaffordable
medical bills is a major barrier to utilization of maternal and child
healthcare services leading to a very high maternal and perinatal mortality and
the inability to attain the MDG4 and MDG5 in many developing countries, Okafor, Obi and Ugwu (2011) conducted
a study which examined the uptakes of obstetric services following introduction
of Free Maternal and Child Health Care (FMCHC) in Enugu State University
Teaching Hospital, Southeast Nigeria and its impact on the maternal and
neonatal healthcare outcome.
Information
from a retrospective comparative study of the utilizations of maternal and
child healthcare services from June to August in 2008 with that of September to
November in 2008 after commencement of the FMCHC were utilized. Information on
all the pregnant women and neonates in their first week of Life that attended
clinic within the period under review was collected from the Medical Records
department of the hospital.
The
study revealed that FMCHC caused tremendous increases in the uptakes of
antenatal booking (202.2%), and hospital delivery (151.8%). It also resulted in
decreased maternal and perinatal mortality by 16.4 per cent and 34 per cent
respectively. It was concluded in the study that implementation of FMCHC can
make MDG4 and MDG5 attainable in sub-Saharan Africa.
Banerjee (2009) investigated the level of information,
education, and communication (IEC) services regarding
pregnancy and child care, received by the women at an MCH clinic of an urban
health center of Kolkata. A community-based, cross-sectional,
observational study was undertaken over a period of six months, in an urban
health centre (UHC) of Kolkata that caters to a mixed population of 1.18 from
all sections of the community. The study subjects comprised 400 antenatal (AN)
and postnatal (PN) mothers and mothers of children under five (U5) years.
To determine sample size, P was taken as 0.5, considering the theory
of probability that 50 per cent are likely to have received the services, which also
gives the maximum sample size. Thus, sample comprised 400 women, considering 95
per cent confidence interval and allowing 10
per cent error.
The
number of under 5 children was noted from the records, and the estimated number
of AN and PN mothers at one point of time were calculated from the birth rate
and population of the area during the previous year. To determine the size of
these different groups within the sample, approximately 15 per cent of the
total population in each group was taken. Thus, the sample comprised 350 U5
children and 50 AN and PN mothers. Only one person was selected from each
household if more than one eligible participant was found.
Data
was collected by house visits and interview method, using a pre tested, semi
structured schedule which included IEC services, received by the mothers,
regarding important points about pregnancy and child care, in the AN and PN
period. Proportion of women receiving such services regarding issues under
consideration was analyzed.
Results
show that warning signs of danger was explained to
only 10 per cent of the AN and PN women.
Advice regarding family planning appeared to be the most frequently covered,
though that too was explained to less than half of the subjects. About one
third of the women were advised on breast feeding. Only 8 per cent of the mothers had been told about all issues regarding
pregnancy and child care. Breast feeding and weaning was properly explained to
85.7 and 81.1 per cent of the total mothers
of U5 children. Advice regarding subsequent nutrition was given to 60.9
per cent of mothers. About only a quarter of the
total mothers were advised on home management of diarrhea and acute respiratory
infections. Very few mothers were counseled about the growth pattern of the
children and none were shown the growth chart. Only 12.9 per cent of the mothers were informed about all issues.
Based on the findings above, it was
concluded that provision of information, education, and communication regarding
maternal and child care other than feeding practices was a neglected service in
the health facility where the study was conducted.
Materia, Mehari,
Mele, Rosmini, Stazi, Damen, Basile, Miuccio, Ferrigno
and Miozzo
(1993) conducted a community survey on maternal and child health services
utilization in rural Ethiopia. Cross sectional research design was employed in
the study. The instruments used for data collection were interview and focus
group discussion.
A household
health interview survey on MCH services utilization was carried out among
mothers of child bearing age in 22 villages of a rural district of Arsi region,
Ethiopia, before the launching of an integrated MCH programme.
The result showed that the coverage of
antenatal services was 26 per cent and 61 per cent of
the women who received antenatal care reported having had 3 or more visits.
Antenatal care was positively associated with living within 10 km of the Health
Centre. Twenty-eight percent of the mothers attended the under-5 clinic and
most returned for 3 or more visits. In addition, 99 per cent reported having breast-fed their last child but more
than 25 per cent started weaning only after
the seventh month of age. Differences in practice of treating diarrhoea
according to knowledge of ORS were found. Of the 33 per cent of those with knowledge of ORS, almost 90 per
cent reported use of ORS for treating child's
diarrhoea, showing a positive attitude towards modern health care. The
proportion of women using family planning was 5 per cent, with no difference found between Christians and Muslims.
Audo, Ferguson
and Njoroge (2005) the quality of care
provided by the Kisumu Municipal health facilities in Kenya, and its
effects in the utilization of maternal and child health (MCH) services. A descriptive cross-sectional survey was employed in
studying a total of 482 mothers. Interview was the instrument used for data
collection.
The result of the study revealed that only
40.4 per cent, 53.7
per cent and 45.7 per cent had respectively used Municipal facilities for
antenatal services (ANC), immunization and treatment of their children the last
time they required such a service. This translates to by-pass rates for
Municipal health facilities of 59.5 per cent, 46.3 per cent and
54.3 per cent respectively for the three
services. By-pass was higher for the more central urban catchment areas than
the more peripheral ones, a finding that was associated with the socio-economic
status of the respondents and the relative location of the municipal facilities
vis-a-vis competing facilities, mainly the District and Provincial hospitals.
The main reasons cited for by-pass were
poor care (21%), lack of drugs and supplies (17%) and lack of/poor laboratory
services (12%). From the facility audit, most of the clinics had a reasonable
capacity to offer basic health care with only three scoring less than 50
per cent in the scale used. The worst areas were
in availability of drugs, equipment and management issues. There was a strong
relationship between the perceived quality of care and utilization of MCH
services as well as by-pass. The capacity of the facilities to offer care was
however not associated with utilization of MCH services or by-pass. However, it
was concluded in the study that there is under-utilization of Municipal health
facilities for MCH services. This is related to the perceived poor quality of
care in the facilities. Perception of quality is influenced by a person's
socio-economic status especially education.
Mwaniki, Kabiru
and Mbugua
(2002) researched utilization of antenatal and maternity services by mothers
seeking child welfare services in Mbeere District, Eastern Province of Kenya.
The Cross-sectional, descriptive research design
was employed in the study. Two hundred mothers bringing their children aged one
year and below to the child welfare clinic between September and December 2000
were studied.
The study revealed that the
proportion of mothers who utilized health facilities for antenatal and
maternity services was 97.5 per cent and 52
per cent, respectively. Utilization of
health facilities for maternity services was significantly influenced by number
of children and distance to health facility in that, as number of children
increased, utilization of maternity services reduced. Mothers living less than
5 km to a health facility utilized the services better than those living 5 km
and beyond. Among the reasons given by the mothers (individual respondents and
through Focus Group Discussions) regarding dissatisfaction with the services
offered included shortage of drugs and essential supplies, lack of commitment
by staff, poor quality of food and lack of cleanliness in the health
facilities.
Coverage for antenatal services was
high among mothers during their last pregnancy. However, only about half of the
mothers interviewed utilized health facilities for maternity services (labour
and delivery). The major constraints experienced by the mothers as they sought
for the services (as reported by individual respondents and through Focus Group
Discussions) included lack of transport, lack of money for transport and
hospital fee and delay in admission to health facility once mothers report in
labour.
Kongnyuy, Hofman, Mlava, Mhango and Van Den
(2009) investigated the availability, utilisation and quality of basic and
comprehensive emergency obstetric care services in Malawi. The study surveyed of all the 73 health
facilities (13 hospitals and 60 health centres) that provide maternity services
in the three districts (population, 2,812,183).
Result
of the study shows that there
were 1.6 comprehensive emergency obstetric care (CEmOC) facilities per 500,000
population and 0.8 basic emergency obstetric care (BEmOC) facilities per
125,000 population. About 23 per cent of deliveries were conducted in
emergency obstetric care (EmOC) facilities and the met need for emergency
obstetric complications was 20.7 per cent. The case fatality rate for emergency
obstetric complications treated in health facilities was 2.0
per cent. Up to 86.7
per cent of pregnant women attended
antenatal clinic at least once and only 12.0 per cent of them attend postnatal clinic at
least once. There was a shortage of qualified staff and unequal distribution
with more staff in hospitals leaving health centres severely understaffed.
The total number of CEmOC facilities
was adequate but the distribution is unequal, leaving some rural areas with
poor access to CEmOC services. There are no functional BEmOC facilities in the
three districts.
Vallières, McAuliffe, Palmer, Magbity and Bangura
(2013) conducted a research which assessed the effects of both
mobile phones and 7-11 timed and targeted counseling (7-11/ttC) mobile
application on health workers’ motivation and health care service delivery
structures in Sierra Leone given that Sierra Leone is consistently ranked among the
countries with the highest maternal mortality ratio (970 per 100,000), and that
women in Sierra Leone have a 1 in 21 lifetime risk of dying as a result of
pregnancy. The main
objective of the research was to examine changes in Community Health Workers’
motivation, triggered by the introduction of the 7-11/ttC mobile application,
and assess how this mediates health worker performance over time. Motivation
levels will be assessed in conjunction with other factors including:
supervision, organisational commitment, and job satisfaction.
A
longitudinal cohort design to monitor individual and group changes in
motivation, organizational commitment, supervision and job-satisfaction across
three intervention groups over a period of 18 months was employed.
Participants were initially contacted from a list of active CHWs in the area,
provided by the Bonthe District Health Management Team (DHMT). All 333
community health workers on the mainland in addition to one in-charge member of
staff from all 26 health care centres in the area were asked if they were
willing to participate in the study. Within this sample size, both males
and females were represented equally as part of the selection criteria for CHWs
within each PHU. In order to ensure that all CHWs had the same basic level of
7-11/ttC training, CHWs completed the 7-11/ttC training jointly conducted by
the DHMT and World Vision.
The results from systematic reviews of
CHW programmes confirmed that CHWs provided critical links between rural
communities and the formal health system and have been shown to reduce child morbidity
and mortality when compared to usual healthcare services. The study also
revealed that CHWs’ potential however, is hampered by inadequate supervision,
lack of locally relevant incentive systems, loss of motivation, insufficient
recognition and community support, poor connectivity to health facilities, and
knowledge retention problems. Moreover, it was found that higher attrition
rates are often associated with programmes where CHWs are asked to volunteer.
The study recommended that with
appropriate support and sufficient training, CHWs can potentially play a
pivotal role in strengthening health systems in areas with poor human resources
for health. More specifically, they are an important resource for
implementing interventions targeting reductions in neonatal mortality and
tracking women throughout their pregnancy while simultaneously promoting
appropriate maternal and newborn care practices. It was concluded in the study
that the motivation of CHWs and the risk of high attrition rates therefore have
important implications for the effectiveness, success, cost, credibility and
continuity of CHW-based programmes.
IRIN News (2006) reported a finding on
the side effects of free maternal and child health services in Burundi. The
source of information was through the mothers and children hospital health
records. The reports revealed that a new
policy of free medical care for Burundian mothers and children was intended to
improve their lives; instead it has crippled the nation's health system;
that public hospitals in Burundi have recorded
double, sometimes triple, the number of patients since a presidential directive
for free paediatric and maternal health services was implemented on 1 May; and
that overcrowded wards, a shortage of doctors and other medical staff, as well
as patients' inability to afford prescribed medications are some of the
challenges health officials are now facing.
The
study recommend that the government should increase medical staff, compel all
health centres to remain open 24 hours and reinforce weekend teams to cope with
the growing influx of patients. In addition to recruiting more staff, the
government needed to increase salaries in order to stem an exodus of doctors
from government service.
Summary of Literature
Review
The
focus of the present study is to investigate the level of provision and
utilization of free MCH services among the child-bearing mothers in Igbo-Eze
North LGA of Enugu State. Literature revealed that Nigeria is second country
(after India) with highest cases of maternal and child mortality and morbidity.
This led to the introduction of free MCH services in most states in Nigeria
including Enugu State. Yet, literature consistently report that there is still
high rate of maternal and child mortality and morbidity.
In the present
study, the free MCH services are those
free health services given to mothers and their children regardless of their
ability to pay for the services in order to reduce the rate of maternal and
child death and achieve the optimal health of both the mother and her child.
Provision and utilization of MCH services remains the only proven tool for
reducing the rate of maternal and child mortality. Definitions of concepts such
as provision, utilization, and extent as given by different authors were
x-rayed.
Certain variables have
been found to influence the extent of provision and utilization of MCH
services. One of such variables is economic status. Increased income was
documented to have a positive effect on the utilization of modern health care
services. Also, women's involvement in gainful employment empowers women to
take part in decision-making processes about health care in the family.
Mother’s level of
education was also shown to influence the extent of utilization of MCH services.
It is argued that better educated women are more aware of health problems; know
more about the availability of health care services; and use this information
more effectively to maintain or achieve good health status. It was also found
that a higher level of maternal education results in improved child survival
because health services that effectively prevent fatal childhood diseases are
used to a greater extent by mothers with higher education than by those with
little or no education.
Apart from mother’s
level of education, age of mother was also shown to influence the extent of
utilization of MCH services.
Findings on how age influences health care utilization are not consistent. Some
reports show that older women utilize health services more than their younger
counterparts but the reverse is reported by some other studies. The third school of thought believes that one would
naturally seek care when distressed irrespective of one’s age. This means that
age has no influence on the mothers’ extent of utilization of health services.
The location and
quality of services available are also important factors affecting MCH services
utilization. Proximity to a health facility has been found to affect the use of
MCH services especially in rural areas as these facilities are usually located
at long distances. For many, lack of transportation and/or considerations of
the cost of transportation serve as mitigating factors to healthcare seeking.
The theories of anchor
in the present study are: the theory of health seeking-behaviour by Anderson and Newman
(1973)
and the attachment theory by Bolby (1969). The tenet of the theory of health
seeking-behaviour is that utilization of health services depends the
predisposing (such age, gender etc); enabling factor like income level; and
need factor (perceived needs and evaluated needs). The tenet of the Attachment
theory is that there is universal human tendency
to prefer certain familiar companions over other people, especially when ill,
injured, or distressed.
Literature
revealed that the rate of maternal and child mortality globally is unacceptably
high especially in developing countries including Nigeria despite the widely
publicized free health programmes and policies which target reduction of
maternal and child mortality. This led to copious studies on the extent of
provision and utilization of free maternal and child health services. However,
most of the literatures on the topic describe the situation as it exists
elsewhere. None of such studies, to the best of the knowledge of the present
researcher, has been conducted in Igbo-Eze North Local Government of Enugu
State. The present study fills the gap.
References
Abbas,
A. A., & Walkern, G. J. A. (1986).
Determinants of the utilization of maternal and child health services in
Jordan. International Journal of Epidemiology, 15, 404–407.
Addisse, M. (2003).
Maternal and child health care. Ethiopia
Public Health Training Initiative. Retrieved from http://www.cartercenter.org/resources/pdfs/health/eph
ti/library/lecture_notes/health_science_students/LN_maternal_care_final.pdf
.
Adenuwagun,
Z. A., & Adekunle, L. (1976). An
investigationof the status and problems of Environmental sanitation in schools
in Benin, Nigeria. Paper presented in a seminar at University of Nigeria,
Nsukka.
Airey,
T. (1989). The impact of road construction on
hospital in-patient catcment in the Meru district of Keneya. Social Science and Medicine, 29, 95–105.
Alakija,
W. (2000). Essentials of community
health: Primary health care and health management. Benin City: Ambik Press.
AlHilfy, T. K. Y., & Esaa, A.
(2007). Mothers knowledge and
attitude regarding childhood survival. Retrieved from http://www.mejfm.com/journal/Jan
2007/mother-child.htm.
Andersen, R. M. (2008). National health
surveys and the behavioral model of health services use. Med Care, 46(7), 647-53.
Andersen, R. M., & Davidson, P. L.
(2001). Improving access to care in America: individual and contextual indicators.
In R. M. Andersen, T. H. Rice, & E. F. Kominski (eds). Changing the U.S. health care system: Key issues in health services,
policy, and management. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Andersen,
R. M., & Newman, J. F. (1973).
Social and individual determinants of medical care utilization in the United
States. Milbank Memorial Quarterly, 51, 95–124.
Audo, M. O., Ferguson A.,
& Njoroge, P. K.
(2005). Quality of health care and its
effects in the utilisation of maternal and child health services in Kenya. Retrieved
from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16463747.
Banerjee, B. (2009). Information, Education, and
Communication Services in MCH Care Provided at an Urban Health Center.
Retrieved from http://www.ncbi. nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2822188/.
Becker,
S., Peters, D. H., Gray, R. H., Gultiano, C., & Blake, R. E. (1993). The
determinants of use of maternal and child health services in Metro Cebu, the
Philippines. Health Transition Review, 3, 77–89.
Bennette,
J. F. (1990). Child survival. In M. H. Watlaco, & K. Giri (Eds). Health care for women and children in
developing countries. California: Third Party Publishing Company.
Bowlby
J. (1969). Attachment and
loss: Vol. 1. New York: Basic
Books
Bulut,
A. (1995). Post partum family planning and health needs of low income in
Istanbul. Studies in Family Planning, 26 (6).
Canadian Institute for Health
Information-CIHI (2001). Canada's health
care providers. Retrieved from http://secure.cihi.ca/cihiweb/dispPage.jsp?cw_p
age=Ar_35_E.
Chakraborty,
N., Islam, M. A., Chowdhury, R. I., Bari, W., & Akhter, H. H. (2003). Determinants of the use of maternal health
services in rural Bangladesh. Retrieved October 15, 2013 from http://heapro.oxfordjournals.org/content
/18/4/327.full.pdf+html.
Cherry, K. (2013). Attachment theory: The importance of early emotional bonds. Retrieved from http://psychology.about.com/od/loveandattraction/a/attachment
01.htm.
Ciechanowski,
P. S., Walker, E. A., Katon, W. J., & Russo, K. (2002). Attachment theory: A model for health care utilization and somatization. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12140356.
Cousens, S., Blencowe, H., Stanton,
C., Chou, D., Ahmed, S., Steinhardt, L., Creanga, A. A., Tunçalp, O., Balsara,
Z. P., Gupta, S., Say, L., & Lawn, J. E. (2011). National, regional,
worldwide estimates of stillbirth rates in 2009 with trends since 1995: A
systematic analysis. Lancet, 16, 377(9774), 1319-1330.
Department of Health and Human
Services-DHHS (2010). Maternal and child
health. Retrieved from www.dhhs.state.nh.us/dphs/bchs/mch/index.htm.
Dissevelt,
A.G. (1978). Integrated maternal and
child health services: A study at a rural health centre in Kenya. Nairobi :
Royal Tropical Institute.
Ditekemena,
J. (2013). Determinants of male involvement in maternal and child health services
in sub-Saharan Africa: A review.
Retrieved from http://www.reproduct
ive-health-journal.com/content/9/1/32.
Elo, T. I. (1992). Utilization of maternal health-care services in Peru: The role of
women's education. Health
Transition Review, 2, 49–69.
Enyi,
G. S. (2006). Introduction to measurement
and evaluation in universities, polytechnics and colleges of education (a
professional approach). Enugu: Liuco Press.
Farlex (2014). Provision. Retrieved from http://www.thefreedictionary.com/provision.
Fiedler, J. L. (1981). A review of the literature on access and utilization of medical care
with special emphasis on rural primary care. Social
Science and Medicine, 15, 129–142.
Fosu, G.
B. (1994). Childhood morbidity and health
services utilization: Cross-national comparisons of user-related factors from
DHS data. Social Science and Medicine, 38, 1209–1220.
Gemson,
G. S. (2011). Attitude to and practice of
solid waste management among Primary Health Care workers in Taraba State. An
M.Ed project, University of Nigeria, Nsukka.
George, E., & Nwobodo, N.
(2010). Civil Society Health Committee working with State Accountability and
Voice Initiative (SAVI). Retrieved from
http://6072405bd1427c7ba9e2090f363ae3e1reportofenugustatedialogueonhealth.
Govindasamy, P., &
Ramesh, B. M. (1997). Maternal
education and the utilization of maternal and child health services in India. National
Family Health Survey Subject Reports, (5). 3-28.
Hampton, C., & Nagy, K. (2013). Determining Service Utilization.
Retrieved from http://ctb.ku.edu/en/tablecontents/sub_section_main_1046.aspx.
Harrison, K. A. (2009). The struggle
to reduce high maternal mortality in Nigeria. African Journal of Reproductive Health, 13, (3), 1-5.
Hill,
K., Thomas, K., AbouZahr, C., Say, l., Inoue, M., & Suzuki, J. (2007). Estimate
of maternal mortality worldwide between 1990 and 2005: An assessment of
available data. Retrieved from http://estimate-of-maternal-mortality-worldwide-between-1990-2005/.
Hornby,
A. S. (2005). Oxford advanced learner’s
dictionary. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Igbo-Eze
North LGA Ministry of Health-INMH (2013). Immunization
guide book. Unpublished book for immunization trainees.
Ijadunola,
K. T. (2012). Free health services in
Nigeria: How beneficial to the poor? Retrieved from http://dr.-k.-t.ijanola-free-health-services-in-nigeria
.
Indexmundi (2013). Maternal
mortality rate. Retrieved
from http://www.index mundi.com/g/r.aspx?v=2223.
IRIN News (2006). Burundi: Side effects of free maternal and child health services. Retrieved from http://www.irinnews.org/report/59267/burundi-side-effects-of-free-maternal-child-healthcare.
Kiwanuka, S. N., Ekirapa, E. K., Peterson, S., Okui, O., Rahman, M. H., Peters, D., & Pariyo, G. W.
(2008). Access to and utilization of
health services for the poor in Uganda: A systematic review of available
evidence. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18565559.
Kongnyuy, E. J., Hofman, J., Mlava, G., Mhango, C., & Van Den, B. N. (2009). Availability, utilisation and quality of
basic and comprehensive emergency obstetric care services in Malawi.
Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.
nih.gov/pubmed/18581221.
Kusiako, T., Ronsmans, C., &
VanDerm, P. L. (2000). Perinaltal mortality attributable to complications of
child birth in matlab, Bangladesh. Bull
World Health Organ, 78:621-27.
Materia, E., Mehari, W., Mele, A., Rosmini, F., Stazi, M. A., Damen, H. M., Basile, G., Miuccio, G., Ferrigno, L.,
& Miozzo, A.(1993).
A community survey on maternal and child
health services utilization in rural Ethiopia. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8307136.
Medical
News Today-MNT (2005). Child-bearing age. Retrieved from http://www. medicalnewstoday.com/releases/30737.php.
Microsoft
Encarta (2009). Utilization.
Microsoft Encarta Premium DVD.
Mwaniki, P. K., Kabiru, E. W.,
& Mbugua, G. G.
(2002).Utilization of antenatal and
maternity services by mothers seeking child welfare services in Mbeere
District, Eastern Province, Kenya. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
/pubmed/12625672.
Nginya,
M. L. (1980). Rural health development in
Kenya: An analysis of health services availability and utilisation within the
framework of class formation in rural areas. PhD thesis, Bradford
University.
Nisar, N., & White, E. (2003). Factors affecting utilization of antenatal
care among the reproductive age group women (15-49 years) in an urban squatter
settlement of Karachi. Retrieved from jpma.org.pk/full_article_text.php?article_id=065.
Nitai
C., Islam, M. A., Chowdhury, R. I., Bari W.,
& Akhter, H. H. (1993). Determinants
of the use of maternal health services in rural Bangladesh.
Retrieved from http://heapro.oxfordjournals.org/content/18/4/327.long.
Normon, P.
Loper, R. Carcamo, M., & Galindo, D. (1993). Research on impact of prenatal reproduction health
programme in Materno-Infentil Tegucigalpa Honduras. World Health Statistics Quarterly.
Nwachukwu,
C. O. (2007). Research methods and
statistics for management and social sciences, applied sciences and education.
Nsukka: FIJAC Academy.
Obermeyer,
C.M., & Potter, J.E. (1991). Maternal health care utilization patterns in
Jordan: A study of patterns and determinants. Studies in Family Planning,
22 (3), 177–187.
Okafor, I. I., Obi, S. N., &
Ugwu, E. O. (2008). Impact of Free Maternal and Child Healthcare programme on maternal and
neonatal healthcare outcome in Enugu State of Nigeria. Retrieved from
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/222 88319.
Okeibunor, J. C., Onyenecho, N.
G., & Okonofua, F. E. (2010). Policy
and programs for reducing maternal mortality in Enugu State, Nigeria.
Retrieved from www.researchgate.net/publication/228716810_policy_and_programs_for_reducing_maternal_mortality_in_enugu_state_nigeria.
Oklahoma State Department Health-OSDH
(2013). Maternal and Child Health
services. Retrieved from www.ok.gov/health/child_and _family_health/maternal
child_health_service/.
Okonofua, F. E. (2006). Positioning maternal and child health for
improving life expectancy in Nigeria. Paper presented at a presidential
forum of Health, Aso Rock Presidential Villa, Abuja.
Okonofua, F. E. (2010). Reducing
Maternal Mortality in Nigeria: An approach through policy research and capacity
building. African Journal of Reproductive
Health, 14, 3, 9-13.
Onuzulike, N. M. (2004). Health care delivery system. Owerri:
Achugo Publishers.
Owino, B. (2012). The use of maternal health care
services: Socio-economic and demographic factors—Nyanza, Kenya. IFRA ~ Les Cahiers, 21, 81–122.
Patton,
G. C., Viner, R. M., Linh L. C., Ameratunga, S., & Fatusi, A. O., (2010). Mapping a global
agenda for adolescent health. Journal of
Adolescent Health 47(5): 427–432.
Paul, B.
K. (1991). Health service resources as
determinants of infant death in rural Bangladesh: An empirical study. Social Science and Medicine, 32, 43–49.
Requejo,
J. (2013). Remarkable progress in reducing
child mortality and improving maternal health. Retrieved
from http://www.unicef.org/media/media
_69367.html.
RobDavies, P. E. (2013). What is utilization? Retrieved from http://www.robdavispe.
com/free2/What-02144-is-utilization.html.
Rossiter, C. E ., Chong, H., Lister,
U. G., Bano, Q., Briggs, N. D., Kwempu, C.C., & Memberr, M. T. (2005). Knowledge and practice of safe motherhood
initiative among childbearing mothers. An International Journal of
Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 92, 14-22.
Sargent,
C., & Rawlings, J. (1991). Factors influencing prenatal care among
low-income Jamaican women. Human Organisation, 50 (2).
Singh, P. K., Rai, R. K., Alagarajan,
M. & Singh, L. (2012). Determinants
of maternity care services utilization among married adolescents in rural
India. PLoS ONE 7 (2), 45-72.
Stock,
R. (1983). Distance and utilization of health
facilities in rural Nigeria. Social Science and Medicine, 17, 63–570.
UNICEF
(2013). Maternal and child health.
Retrieved from http://www.unicef.org/
nigeria/children_1926.html.
United Nation International Children
Emergency Fund, UNICEF, (1997). Women’s health in Pakistan. Fact sheets prepared for Pakistan National
Forum on Women’s Health 3-5, 16-17.
United
Nations Environment Programme (2013). Millennium
Development Goals. Retrieved from www.unep.org/documentid=489&l=en.
Vallières, F., McAuliffe, E., Palmer, I., Magbity,
E., & Bangura, A. S. (2013). Supporting and strengthening maternal, neonatal, and
child health services using mobile phones in sierra leone: A research protocol. Retrieved from http://africa.harvard.edu/apj/supporting-strengthening-maternal-neonatal-and-child-health-services-using-mobile-phones-in-sierra-leone-a-research-protocol/.
Vanden, H. O. A., De Mey, W. G., Buddingh, H.,
& Bots, M. L.
(1999). Use of maternal care in a rural
area of Zimbabwe: A population-based study. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10577611.
Vocabulary.com (2013). What
is provision? Retrieved from http://www.vocabulary. com
/dictionary/provision.
WHO (2000). Child mortality. Geneva: WHO.
WHO (2012). Maternal mortality. Retrieved from http://www.who.int/mediacentre
/factsheets/fs348/en/.
Williams
J., & Wilkins, W. U. (2006). Child-bearing age. Retrieved from http://www.
medilexicon.com/medicaldictionary.php?t=1634).
Winikoff,
B. (1987). Assessing the role of family planning in reducing maternal mortality.
Studies in Family Planning, 18 (3).
World Bank (1999).Human development in South Asia: The crisis
of governance. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
No comments:
Post a Comment